Personally, I have the idea of sharing experiences as something unique and intimate. I want to surprise and explore my desires with those who also long to share their first experiences, their first trip abroad, their first home, their first camping trip... I like to feel like I'm someone important in the life of the person I love.
My wife had only one failed attempt at sexual intercourse and I still feel my heart is broken because of it. I'm a strictly monogamous and attached person. Even though I was able to give her pleasure in ways she'll never forget, I'll still be the second person, forever, while she was my first.
Today I'm not a man, but I make my part count. All affection and love are given in a completely fair exchange, the requirements are delivered on my part.
The feeling I convey is this fragility and inexperience, it directly hits my ego. That's why no man expresses himself in this way.
So basically, the fact she had a life before you made you insecure? Look, I understand wanting to share experiences and have special moments, but you have to face the fact that everyone had a life before you came into theirs, and you also had one before anyone came into yours. If that fact makes your heart break, you're searching for the impossible, and I say that because I have too, for a long time, chasing a golden goose, before coming to the hurtful reality that it won't happen.
Special moments don't have to adhere to such strict guidelines. You can be special to someone else while being only part of their lives. You don't have to dedicate 99% of your energy towards someone for them to feel cared and loved. Hell, as much as I want, I can't be mama bear 24/7, that would drain me!
I believe your intentions are true and valid, but again, it is an idealization that will not hold up to real people. Sometimes, you need to have more patience and less intensity, to make things easier not only for the other party, but also for you. Maybe someone in the past has demanded that kind of intensity from you, and that stuck on you, but I'm extrapolating facts at that point.
You seem to be a compassionate and intense person who is going to give your all towards someone else if they return the favor, and that's bound to fail, even if you find someone else to give their 100%. Someone will burn out at some point, and there will be disappointment. I'm sure a lot of people already think you're special in their hearts, but not at the rate you want to.
In short, You don't need to starve yourself waiting for the "main course", just to make it even more special, get some snacks, a drink, maybe a break to go outside and breathe some fresh air, as others do. Make the wait pleasurable, and you'll see the main course ain't gonna taste less good because of it.
